Three war veterans (Mitchum, Ryan and Brodie) meet up in a bar with civilian Joseph Samuels (Levene), and after a few rounds, drunkenly follow Samuels back to his apartment to raid his liquor cabinet. When Samuels is later found beaten to death, Police Captain Finlay (Young) is called in to investigate. It’s quickly apparent that one of the soldiers did the killing, but which one? And just as puzzling, what could be the motive for such a brutal crime?